How to Do Payroll Yourself in 2024 Like A Pro

How to Do Payroll Yourself in 2024 Like A Pro

Unlocking the Secrets of DIY Payroll for 2024
How to Do Payroll Yourself

Navigating the complexities of payroll can often seem like a daunting task, especially for small business owners wearing multiple hats. If you're wondering how to do payroll yourself, you've come to the right place. This comprehensive guide aims to simplify the payroll process, providing you with all the tools, tips, and step-by-step instructions you need to manage your payroll like a pro. But before diving into the nitty-gritty, it's essential to understand the importance of accurate payroll—both for your business and your employees. Let's get started on making your payroll management hassle-free and precise.

The Importance of Accurate Payroll

Running a successful business involves juggling various responsibilities, one of the most crucial being payroll management. So why is accurate payroll so essential? It's not just about the numbers; it's about the ripple effects those numbers can create in your business.

Impact on Small Businesses

Unlike larger corporations with specialized departments, small businesses usually handle payroll with fewer resources. This leaves them more vulnerable to errors and the severe consequences that can follow. Here's a closer look at why precision in payroll is especially crucial for small businesses.

  • Legal Compliance: Adhering to legal standards is non-negotiable. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and other government bodies have strict guidelines about the withholding of federal and state taxes. Payroll errors could mean failing to withhold the correct amount for Social Security or Medicare, leading to penalties that can cripple a small enterprise. This could result in a slew of legal complications, including hefty fines and a tarnished reputation.
  • Impact on Employee Morale: Let's talk about the human element—your employees. Imagine the frustration and distrust that can ensue when an employee finds discrepancies in their paycheck. It's not just about correcting a simple mistake; it's about the erosion of trust and the detrimental impact on team morale. Accurate payroll fosters a positive work environment, which in turn boosts productivity.
  • Financial Stability: Financial stability is the cornerstone of any successful business. Inaccurate payroll can lead to unexpected costs, including back payments and legal fees. Such errors can strain your financial resources, making it challenging to invest in business growth or even handle day-to-day operations.

Grasping Payroll Fundamentals

Understanding the ins and outs of payroll is essential for any business owner. But what exactly does "payroll" entail? At its core, payroll is the process of compensating your employees. It's not just about cutting checks; it's a multifaceted operation that requires meticulous attention to detail. This section will guide you through the basics of payroll, its components, and the importance of staying compliant with various laws and regulations.

Definition of Payroll

Simply put, payroll is the complete process of calculating, distributing, and reporting employee wages. It encompasses various tasks such as tracking work hours, determining pay rates, and withholding the appropriate taxes. Compliance with local, state, and federal regulations is crucial. Failure to comply can result in penalties and even legal repercussions.

Payroll Overview

Components of Payroll

When it comes to payroll, understanding its basic components is the first step toward mastery. Let's break down these elements:

  • Gross Pay: This is the total amount an employee earns before any deductions are made. Gross pay serves as the foundational number for subsequent calculations.
  • Deductions: These are amounts withheld from an employee's gross pay for various reasons, such as income tax, Social Security, and benefits like health insurance. Deductions can be both mandatory and voluntary.
  • Net Pay: This is the amount left after all deductions are accounted for, essentially what your employees take home.

Understanding Key Payroll Laws for Compliance

The risk of not adhering to payroll laws and regulations can be severe, ranging from financial penalties to criminal prosecution. Ensuring compliance is not just a legal necessity; it's also about safeguarding your business reputation and maintaining trust with your employees. Here are some key payroll laws to focus on:

  • Overtime pay: This refers to the additional pay employees receive when they work more than the standard 40-hour workweek. The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) dictates that non-exempt employees must receive overtime pay at a rate of one and a half times their regular rate.
  • Pay frequency: This term indicates how often employees are paid—be it weekly, bi-weekly, semi-monthly, or monthly. Each state may have specific laws dictating the minimum frequency for payroll.
  • Payment methods: This refers to how employees receive their wages. While some employees still prefer traditional paper checks, direct deposit and electronic pay cards are also common. Employers sometimes are required to offer multiple payment options.
  • Payroll Taxes: These are taxes that are withheld from an employee's wages and are paid directly to the government. They include federal and state income taxes, Social Security, and Medicare taxes.
  • Tax forms: Employers are required to file specific forms with the IRS detailing earnings, withholdings, and other payroll-related information. Common forms include W-2s for employees and 1099s for contractors.
  • Paid family leave: This is a mandate in some states, requiring employers to offer paid leave for employees who need to care for a new child or a sick family member. Paid sick time: In many states, employers are required to provide paid sick leave, allowing employees to take time off work due to illness without losing their pay.
  • Worker's compensation insurance: This is a type of insurance that provides wage replacement and medical benefits to employees injured on the job. Most states require employers to carry some form of worker's compensation insurance.
  • Wage garnishments: These are court-ordered withholdings from an employee's wages to pay debts or child support. Employers are obligated to comply with these orders.
  • Recordkeeping requirements: Employers are required to maintain accurate records of employee wages, tax withholdings, and hours worked, usually for at least three years, depending on the jurisdiction.
  • Final paycheck: This refers to the last paycheck an employee receives when they terminate their employment. State laws dictate how quickly an employee must receive this final payment.
  • PTO payout: This term refers to the payout of accrued but unused Paid Time Off (PTO) when an employee leaves the company. Some states mandate that employers must pay out unused PTO.

A Step-by-Step Guide to DIY Payroll

After understanding the importance of payroll laws and the basics of how they work, you're ready to dive into the nitty-gritty of running payroll yourself. In this section, we'll walk you through the essential steps, from gathering tax information to determining a payroll schedule, to help you manage your payroll like a pro. Let's get started.

Step 1: Gathering Essential Tax Information

Navigating the labyrinth of tax obligations is a crucial first step in the payroll process. Before diving into other payroll activities, you'll need to gather specific tax information to ensure you're compliant with federal and local laws. The most fundamental among these is your Employer Identification Number (EIN), a nine-digit number assigned by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). This number is your business's identity in the eyes of the IRS, much like a Social Security number for individuals.

Applying for an EIN is a relatively straightforward process and can be done through various methods. The quickest way is to apply online, which usually results in an immediate EIN assignment. Alternatively, you can apply via fax or mail, although these methods can take up to four business days and one month, respectively.

An EIN isn't just for show; it serves multiple purposes. For starters, you can't open a business bank account without it. The number is also crucial when hiring employees and, of course, for running payroll. It's the cornerstone of your tax forms, so it's essential to apply for one if you haven't already.

Your tax responsibilities don't end at the federal level, however. Depending on where your business operates, you may also need separate tax IDs for each state, county, or even city. These are critical for fulfilling state and local tax obligations, which can vary widely from one jurisdiction to another.

So, before you get lost in the complexities of running your own payroll, make sure you've got all your tax documentation.

Step 2: Employee Withholding Certificate Completion

Once you've secured your EIN and are aware of your tax obligations, the next step is to get your employees involved in the payroll process. Before you can run payroll, each of your employees needs to complete specific tax forms to ensure the proper withholding of federal and local taxes. For traditional employees, this usually means filling out a Form W-4. If you're working with freelancers or independent contractors, you'll need them to complete a Form W-9.

Note: Freelancers and contractors require special attention since their Form 1099s follow different rules and procedures.

Completing these forms accurately is crucial for both the employer and the employee. For the employee, incorrect information could lead to an unwelcome surprise during tax season, like owing additional taxes. For you, as the employer, incorrect forms can result in penalties from the IRS. So, accuracy is not just recommended; it's mandated.

After collecting the forms, it's not enough to file them away and forget about them. These documents have to be updated when there are personal or financial changes, like a change in marital status or allowances. There are also specific deadlines for when these forms should be submitted to the IRS, depending on your employees' circumstances.

Step 3: Deciding on a Payroll Schedule

After you've gathered essential tax information and ensured that your employees have filled out the appropriate withholding certificates, it's time to decide how often you'll pay them. There's some flexibility here, but keep in mind that you're also bound by state and federal guidelines, as well as any collective bargaining agreements or union demands.

The four primary types of pay schedules are weekly, bi-weekly, semi-monthly, and monthly. Each pay period has its pros and cons. For instance, a weekly pay schedule might be administrative overkill, while a monthly one could make budgeting harder for your workers.

Choosing the Right Schedule

The frequency with which you pay your employees may hinge on several factors, such as your business's cash flow and operational complexity. Bi-weekly payments are the most common, offering a good balance between administrative burden and employee satisfaction. However, your cash flow and the additional costs associated with payroll—like direct deposit fees or check mailing costs—should guide your decision. Remember, a schedule that aligns with your business operations and financial capacity is likely to benefit both you and your employees in the long run.

Step 4: Calculating Employees Gross Pay

After setting your tax arrangements and payroll schedule, you'll need to determine your employees' gross pay. The approach differs for hourly and salaried workers. For hourly employees, you'll multiply their hourly rate by the number of hours worked. Don't overlook any overtime, usually calculated at a higher rate.

For instance, let's say an employee has worked 85 hours in a biweekly pay period at a rate of $10 per hour. If your standard pay period is 80 hours, you would calculate as follows:

  • Regular pay: 80 hours x $10 = $800
  • Overtime pay: 5 hours x $15 = $75
  • Gross pay: $800 + $75 = $875

Salaried employees are a bit simpler: just divide their annual salary by the number of pay periods. If you give bonuses, be aware that they're subject to different tax requirements and should be calculated separately.

Automated time-tracking systems tools like OnTheClock can speed up this process. If you prefer manual calculations, be prepared to invest more time, especially with a large team.

Step 5: Calculating Payroll Deductions

After determining your employees' gross pay, the next critical step is to calculate the necessary payroll deductions using the information provided on their W-4 forms. Deductions generally fall into one of three categories: pretax, federal and state-mandated, and post-tax deductions.

Pretax deductions often encompass contributions to retirement plans and flexible savings accounts. Federal and state-mandated deductions, on the other hand, include charges for FICA, Medicare, and Social Security. Additionally, there are post-tax deductions such as wage garnishments and Roth IRA contributions to consider.

Beyond these standard deductions, some businesses may also need to account for local taxes and workers' compensation premiums. Ensuring the accuracy of these figures is crucial, not only for the financial well-being of your business but also for compliance with federal and state regulations.

If manual calculations aren't your strong suit, a variety of payroll calculators are available to automate this process. These tools can handle everything from federal and state income taxes to FICA taxes, which for the year 2023 stand at a rate of 6.2% for Social Security and 1.45% for Medicare.

Step 6: Net Pay Calculation and Payroll Execution

After working your way through deductions and withholding, the next step is to determine your employees' net pay. In its simplest form, net pay is calculated by subtracting all deductions from the gross pay, like so: Gross pay−deductions=net pay.

Net pay, commonly referred to as take-home pay, is the amount your employees receive at the end of each pay period. It's a good idea to create a pay stub for each employee detailing their earnings and deductions. This not only keeps your records straight but also provides employees with transparent insights into their compensation.

Once you've ascertained the net pay, you're ready to run your first payroll. You have several options: direct deposit to employees' bank accounts, sending checks by mail, or utilizing pay cards for added convenience. Regardless of the method you choose, precision is key. Mistakes can lead to compliance issues and erode trust among your staff.

Step 7: Correcting Errors and Paying Payroll Taxes

Even with the most meticulous planning, mistakes can happen in payroll processing. Whether it's a typo in an employee's name, miscalculated payments, or discrepancies in overtime, swift action is crucial to rectify any errors. Equally important is the need to settle your payroll taxes accurately and promptly.

Identifying errors requires a keen eye and consistent review of pay stubs and employee records. If an error comes to your attention, make the necessary corrections immediately to maintain trust and legal compliance. Use authorized correction procedures, usually outlined by your payroll software or accountant, to ensure accuracy in revisions.

Common Payroll Mistakes:
  • Misspellings: Always double-check names, addresses, and other personal information.
  • Incorrect Payment Calculations: Miscalculations can happen, especially with deductions or overtime.
  • Overtime Discrepancies: Ensure overtime rates and hours are correctly accounted for.
  • Outdated Tax Rates: Tax rates change; make sure you're using the most current ones.
  • Pay Period Dates: Incorrect pay period dates can result in delayed or incorrect payments.

Step 8: Filing and Reporting to Tax Agencies

After running payroll, your next responsibility is to report and remit taxes to federal, state, and local tax agencies. This task isn't just a matter of compliance; it's also essential for maintaining your business's good standing with the IRS and other agencies. To meet federal and state regulations, you'll need to:

  • Deposit Federal Taxes: To meet IRS requirements, use the Electronic Federal Tax Payment System (EFTPS) for all federal tax deposits, including employee withholdings and FICA taxes.
  • File State Tax Reports: If your state has an income tax, adhere to its specific payment schedule and guidelines for both income and unemployment taxes.
  • Make FUTA Payment: Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA) payments must be sent to the IRS on a quarterly basis.
  • File Form 940: This is the Annual Federal Unemployment (FUTA) Tax Return.
  • File Form 941: File this form every quarter to settle your FICA taxes.

By staying organized and attentive to deadlines, you fulfill not just a legal obligation but also contribute to your business's financial integrity.

Step 9: Maintaining Organized Payroll Records

Maintaining well-organized payroll records is essential for smooth business operations and legal compliance. Should the IRS audit your company, these records become indispensable. Federal law requires keeping specific employee data for at least three to four years after their departure. This includes not just basic details like names and addresses but also comprehensive payment information, W-4 forms, and records of each pay period.

To manage this effectively, consider using the following tips:

  • Utilize secure cloud storage for digital copies of all essential payroll documents.
  • Label each file clearly for easy retrieval.
  • Conduct periodic reviews to ensure that your records remain accurate and up-to-date.

Tools for Streamlining Payroll Management

Managing payroll manually can be a daunting task. Thankfully, an array of tools can simplify the process, leaving you free to focus on other critical aspects of your business. From specialized payroll software to time-tracking solutions and accounting software that seamlessly integrates with your payroll system, these tools can make your life much easier.

In the following sections, we'll delve into how each of these tools can be a game-changer for your business, whether you're a startup or an established enterprise.

Selecting the Right Payroll Software

Navigating the multitude of payroll software options can feel like walking through a maze. Your choice will depend on various factors like your business size, payroll complexity, and desired level of automation. To guide your selection, consider criteria such as cost, scalability, and integration capabilities. Cost is often a deciding factor, but don't overlook essential features for the sake of saving money. Scalability ensures your chosen software grows with your business, while integration capabilities allow for seamless interaction with existing accounting or HR systems.

Popular software options

  • QuickBooks Payroll: Ideal for businesses already using QuickBooks accounting software.
  • ADP: Suitable for larger businesses with more complex payroll needs.
  • Gusto: Known for its user-friendly interface, it is perfect for small to medium-sized businesses.
By taking the time to align your business needs with the features of these software options, you'll be well on your way to making an informed decision that could save you significant time and money.

Leveraging Time Tracking Tools

While selecting the right payroll software is crucial, tracking employee hours accurately is equally important. Time-tracking tools can range from traditional punch clocks to sophisticated software integrated with your payroll system. These tools not only help in calculating pay but also provide insights into employee productivity and can even assist in resource planning. Choosing a system that aligns with your business needs is paramount, so consider factors like ease of use, integration capabilities, and cost when making your selection.

Time tracking tools for payroll

How OnTheClock Can Help You to Run Your Payroll

Looking for a simpler way to handle time tracking and payroll? OnTheClock has got you covered. Our tool easily syncs with many payroll systems like Gusto, Paychecks, or ADP, eliminating manual data transfers. Here are some specific benefits for payroll:

  • Streamlined Timesheets: Review and approve timesheets quickl, making your payroll process faster.
  • Error Reduction: Automated features minimize the chance of costly payroll mistakes.
  • Flexibility: Various clock-in options, from mobile devices to biometric time clocks, adapt to your business needs.


OnTheClock comes with other handy features like GPS tracking and PTO management. The user-friendly dashboard and flexible clock-in options make OnTheClock a win-win for any business looking to save time and reduce errors.

Simplify Your Payroll with OnTheClock!

Upgrade to a seamless time tracking and payroll experience.

Integrating with Accounting Software

Integrating payroll and accounting systems can be a game-changer for your business. Unlike standalone payroll software, which zeroes in on employee compensation, accounting platforms offer a panoramic view of your business's finances—covering everything from invoicing to expense management and detailed financial reporting.

By merging these two systems, you can bid farewell to cumbersome manual data entry, thereby reducing the likelihood of errors. Plus, real-time updates mean your financial statements are always up-to-date.

When selecting accounting software to connect to your payroll system, it's crucial to pick one that's compatible with your current setup, whether you're using NetSuite or QuickBooks.

Weighing the Pros and Cons of DIY Payroll

As a small business owner, you might wonder if managing your own payroll is a viable option. Doing payroll by hand or using manual methods might seem daunting, but it comes with both advantages and disadvantages that merit consideration. In this section, we'll delve into the pros and cons, as well as some risk mitigation strategies you can employ.

Advantages of Managing Payroll Yourself

Cost-Efficiency: One of the most compelling reasons to handle your own payroll is the potential for cost savings. Outsourcing payroll services can be expensive, especially for small businesses operating on tight budgets. By taking on the payroll process yourself, you can minimize overhead costs.

Control Over Process: Managing your payroll in-house gives you direct control over the payroll processing. This means you can make real-time adjustments, such as amending an employee's pay or tax deductions, without having to go through a third-party service. You're in the driver's seat when it comes to processing payroll, ensuring that every detail aligns with your business needs.

Flexibility: Another benefit of doing your own payroll is the flexibility it offers. You can choose a payroll schedule that suits your business needs, whether that's weekly, bi-weekly, or monthly. You can also adapt your payroll process to include special bonuses or commissions without the rigidity of a third-party service.

Potential Disadvantages of DIY Payroll

Time Constraints: While managing your own payroll can save you money, it can also be time-consuming. Payroll isn't just about cutting checks; it involves a myriad of tasks, such as calculating taxes, keeping accurate records, and more. The time you spend on these tasks could be used on other critical aspects of your business.

Risk of Errors: Handling payroll manually increases the likelihood of errors, ranging from miscalculations to missing tax deadlines. Errors in payroll can lead to unhappy employees and in worst-case scenarios, could result in legal repercussions.

Legal Implications: Speaking of legal matters, managing your own payroll means you're solely responsible for complying with tax laws and regulations. Failure to accurately calculate federal, state, or local taxes could result in fines or legal action.

Exploring Alternatives to DIY Payroll

Managing your own payroll might not be the right fit for every business owner. Time constraints, the complexity of tax laws, or even the sheer number of employees might make you consider other avenues. Let's explore the alternatives as well as factors you should consider when making your choice.

Hiring an Accountant: A Viable Alternative?

If your business has grown to a substantial size, bringing an in-house accountant on board can be a strategic move. Such professionals can manage a range of financial tasks, including payroll, using specialized software like QuickBooks to ensure everything runs smoothly. An accountant's expertise can help you navigate complex tax laws and regulations, adding an extra layer of assurance to your financial operations.

However, the cost of a full-time, in-house accountant may be prohibitive for smaller enterprises. Businesses often wait until their workforce reaches a certain size, justifying the need for a dedicated accountant. In the interim, you may find that other options, like third-party services, align more closely with your budget and needs.

Hire a Third Party Services

For those who find the cost of an in-house accountant too steep, outsourcing to a third-party payroll provider might be the ideal solution. These specialized services handle payroll responsibilities for multiple clients, making it a cost-effective option even for businesses with smaller payrolls.

Providers vary in the level of service they offer. Some take care of every aspect of payroll, from calculating wages to filing tax forms, allowing you to focus entirely on your core business activities. Others offer a more piecemeal approach, providing support for specific tasks while you handle the rest. The key is to identify the right level of service that meets both your operational needs and budget constraints.

Whether you opt for an in-house accountant or outsource to a third-party service, the aim is to ensure that payroll runs as efficiently and accurately as possible.

Concluding Thoughts on DIY Payroll

Navigating the complexities of payroll is a critical task for any business, especially one with employees. Small business owners often find themselves at a crossroads, weighing the pros and cons of handling payroll in-house against the potential benefits of outsourcing.

One thing is clear: accuracy is paramount. Even minor errors in payroll can lead to disgruntled employees, not to mention the legal repercussions that can significantly tarnish your business's reputation and financial standing. So, whether you opt to manage payroll yourself or enlist the help of a service, meticulous attention to detail is essential.

Ultimately, your decision should be guided by a blend of factors—your comfort with financial management, your team's size, and the resources you can allocate to payroll. Remember, the choice you make will have a lasting impact on your business, so it's crucial to choose wisely.

Answers to Your Payroll Queries

Navigating the world of payroll can be daunting, especially if you're just starting out. To help you on this journey, we've put together a small business guide that answers some of the most common questions we've encountered. Let's jump right into it.


Yes, you can manage payroll yourself, especially if you're running a small business with a limited number of employees. However, be prepared to dedicate time and effort to ensure accuracy and compliance with tax laws.


A payroll calculator is a tool that helps you compute employee paychecks, taking into account factors like hours worked, tax rates, and other deductions. It's particularly useful for your first payroll run to ensure you get the numbers right.


While not strictly necessary, payroll software can simplify the process, reduce errors, and save you time. Some software even integrates with time-tracking systems to further streamline your operations.


The frequency of running payroll depends on several factors, including state laws and your company's policy. Common schedules are weekly, bi-weekly, and monthly.


You can pay your employees through direct deposit, paper checks, or even cash, although the latter is generally not recommended due to the lack of a paper trail.


Pretax deductions are amounts taken out of an employee's paycheck before taxes are applied. These often go towards benefits like health insurance or retirement plans.


Exempt employees are not subject to overtime pay laws, while non-exempt employees are eligible for overtime. The classification depends on factors like job duties and salary levels.


It's advisable to keep payroll records for at least three years, although some types of records may need to be kept longer to comply with federal and state laws. For more in-depth information, consult additional resources like the IRS website.

OnTheClock Employee Time Tracking

Written by

OnTheClock Team

OnTheClock is the perfect app for business that want to keep track of their employees' time without spending hours doing it. With OnTheClock, you can forget about the old way of doing things.

Do you want to know more about how OnTheClock works?

Leave Your Thoughts...

(required, will be shown)
(required, will not be shown)